The three plugins differ less in what they can do than in where each vendor draws the free line. On 12 November 2026, Rank Math listed a redirect manager and a 404 monitor as free, Yoast listed IndexNow and redirects under Premium, and AIOSEO put its redirection manager in Pro. All three describe importers for competitors. We name no winner, because the right pick depends on which of these features you need.
Disclosure. We have no affiliate relationship with Yoast, Rank Math or AIOSEO, and no link here earns us money. SiteTiller is not a WordPress SEO plugin and works alongside any of them. Prices are on the pricing comparison.
Usage and maintenance, from our dataset
These numbers come from the WordPress.org API on 2026-11-12. Installs are rounded buckets, and stars are the rating divided by 20.
| Measure | Yoast SEO | Rank Math SEO | All in One SEO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Active installs | 10,000,000+ | 4,000,000+ | 2,000,000+ |
| Rating (ratings count) | 4.8 stars (27,820) | 4.8 stars (7,524) | 4.7 stars (5,235) |
| Version, last updated | 28.8, 2026-10-27 | 1.0.282, 2026-11-10 | 5.0.5, 2026-11-04 |
| Requires WordPress, tested up to | 7.0, 7.1.4 | 6.7, 7.1.4 | 5.7, 7.1.4 |
| Support threads resolved, last two months | 42 of 46 | 34 of 39 | 26 of 27 |
| First listed on WordPress.org | 2010-10-11 | 2018-11-19 | 2007-03-30 |
Feature table, as each vendor states it
Tags show the source: A is the Yoast WordPress.org page, B is Rank Math's, C is AIOSEO's. We did not install or test anything. The words free, Premium and Pro are the vendor's own. Where a page gives no label, we write not stated.
| Feature | Yoast SEO | Rank Math | AIOSEO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Schema output | Free: Schema.org output; Premium adds more types [A] | Free: 16+ types; PRO: 20+ types, builder, templates, conditional markup [B] | Free FAQ lists schema; the Pro box also lists smart schema, so the split is not stated [C] |
| XML sitemaps | Free [A] | Free, with custom post type support [B] | Free sitemap; the Pro box lists a sitemap suite [C] |
| Redirects | Premium: manager with CSV import and export [A] | Free: redirection manager; PRO: bulk redirect actions [B] | Pro: redirection manager [C] |
| 404 monitor | Not stated [A] | Free [B] | Described under the Pro redirection module [C] |
| IndexNow | Premium [A] | Instant Indexing module for Bing and Yandex, listed in the PRO section [B] | Listed; tier not stated [C] |
| Import from other plugins | Built-in tools; plugins not named [A] | Free: Yoast, AIO SEO, SEOPress, Redirection [B] | Importer for Yoast, Rank Math, SEOPress [C] |
| llms.txt | Free, with manual page selection [A] | Not mentioned [B] | Generates the file; tier not stated [C] |
| AI features | AI tools come with Premium; page is ambiguous on which are free [A] | Content AI can be started free, needs a connected account; AI Link Genius is PRO [B] | AI content, image and schema generators; the Pro box lists content and image generation [C] |
| Local, video, news SEO | Included with Premium [A, E] | Not stated on this page [B] | Local SEO is Pro; Pro adds video and news sitemaps [C, F] |
The source tags E and F are the Yoast product page and the AIOSEO pricing page, both in Sources.
Installs, drawn to scale
Choose each one if the documentation matches your need
- Choose Yoast SEO if you want the llms.txt feature, schema output and sitemaps in the free plugin, and you accept paying for redirects and IndexNow. Its Premium subscription also bundles Local, Video and News SEO.
- Choose Rank Math if you want redirects, a 404 monitor and a one-click Yoast import without paying first. Its PRO tier adds a schema builder and bulk actions.
- Choose AIOSEO if you want an importer covering Yoast, Rank Math and SEOPress, and you are comfortable with Pro unlocking its redirection manager and local SEO.
Nothing here covers ranking results, page speed or ease of use. For those, test on a staging copy.
Methodology
We read the three WordPress.org plugin pages on 2026-11-12 and recorded each statement with its free or paid label. Where a vendor's page contradicts itself, we say so. Usage numbers come from our dataset, published unchanged. Vendor pages change often, so recheck before buying. To see which tags your site prints today, run the WordPress SEO audit tool or the schema checker. See the ten-plugin dataset for others, and the switching checklist before you migrate.
Questions people ask
Which of the three has a free redirect manager?
Per its WordPress.org page, Rank Math lists a redirection manager among its free features. The Yoast page shows redirect tooling only in its Premium list, and the AIOSEO FAQ says Pro adds the redirection manager.
Can I switch between them without starting over?
All three pages describe importers. Rank Math names Yoast, AIO SEO and SEOPress as sources, and AIOSEO names Yoast, Rank Math and SEOPress. Yoast describes built-in import and export tools without naming plugins. Follow our switching checklist and compare page source before and after.
Why do some cells say not stated?
Where a vendor page gives no free or paid label for a feature, we say so rather than guess. The AIOSEO page, for example, lists schema in both its free FAQ and its Pro box.
Do I need one of these if I use SiteTiller?
SiteTiller is not a WordPress SEO plugin and works alongside any of them. A plugin writes tags. SiteTiller checks what your pages and tags look like to search engines.
Related
Sources
- WordPress.org: Yoast SEO plugin page, accessed 2026-11-12.
- WordPress.org: Rank Math SEO plugin page, accessed 2026-11-12.
- WordPress.org: All in One SEO plugin page, accessed 2026-11-12.
- SiteTiller dataset: 10 WordPress SEO plugins, WordPress.org API, 12 Nov 2026, accessed 2026-11-12.
- Yoast: SEO Premium product page, accessed 2026-11-12.
- AIOSEO: pricing page, accessed 2026-11-12.