Alternate page with proper canonical tag means Google found a page whose canonical tag points to another page that is indexed. Google says there is nothing you need to do. Open a few listed URLs and confirm each canonical points to the page you want ranked. Act only when the canonical target is wrong, redirects elsewhere, or is itself blocked from indexing.
What the status says
The Page indexing report help describes it in one sentence: the page correctly points to the canonical page, which is indexed, so no action is required. The URL appears in the not indexed list because Google keeps one version of duplicated content and files the others as alternates. A long list here is typical on sites with tracking parameters, separate mobile or AMP URLs, or filtered category pages.
Normal cases and problem cases
| What you see | Verdict | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| URL with a tracking or sort parameter, canonical pointing to the clean URL | Normal | Google lists parameters as a common source of duplicates. Confirm the clean URL is indexed |
| AMP page whose canonical is the regular page | Normal | Google names AMP variants as a duplicate source. The regular page should be the indexed one |
| Separate mobile URL pointing to the desktop page | Normal | Check the matching rel=alternate link exists on the desktop page |
| http:// version pointing to https:// | Normal | Google says it prefers HTTPS as canonical |
| Language versions each canonical to the main language | Problem | Google says canonical annotations are not used with hreflang. Each language page should canonical to itself and list alternates with hreflang |
| Product or post canonical to the category page or homepage | Problem | A unique page is being folded into an unrelated one. Fix the template or plugin setting |
| Canonical target returns noindex, 404 or redirects | Problem | The signals contradict each other. Point the canonical at a live indexable page |
| A page you wanted indexed appears here | Problem | Its canonical tag points somewhere else. Compare with Google's chosen canonical in URL Inspection |
How the signals line up
Check one URL in a minute
- Pick a URL from the report that you did not expect to see.
- Run it through the noindex checker, which shows the canonical it finds, any redirect hops and the status code.
- Open the canonical target and confirm it returns 200, carries no noindex, and canonicals to itself.
- In Search Console, inspect the original URL and compare the user-declared canonical with the Google-selected one, as explained in the URL Inspection guide.
The tag should look like this on the preferred page, in the head, with an absolute URL:
<link rel="canonical" href="https://example.com/shoes">
Google accepts the link element only inside the head and calls relative paths not recommended. A plugin or theme that prints the tag in the body, or twice with different values, produces exactly the problem rows above.
When a fix is needed
If the wrong target comes from a template, change the template and not every page. If the canonical points at a redirecting URL, update it to the final address; see page with redirect. If Google ignored your tag and indexed another URL, that is the separate status in duplicate without user-selected canonical. For how the three controls differ, read noindex, robots.txt or canonical.
Why the count can grow
Every new filter, sort option, tracking link or print view can mint another URL that shows the same content. If each one carries a canonical pointing at the clean page, the status list grows while the indexed set stays the same. That is the system working. Growth becomes interesting only when the list contains URLs you publish on purpose, such as service pages or posts, because then a template or plugin is mislabeling real pages as copies of something else.
Google gives no figure for how many alternate pages a healthy site should have, so a high count alone proves nothing. Judge by sampling, not by the total.
Questions people ask
Should I try to get these pages indexed?
Usually not. Google's report help says the page correctly points to an indexed canonical page and that there is nothing you need to do. Indexing the duplicate as well would defeat the purpose of the canonical tag.
Is this the same as Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user?
No. In the alternate status, Google accepted the canonical you declared. In the duplicate status, Google indexed a different URL than the one you declared. The second one is the conflict, covered in our duplicate-canonical guide.
Can I remove the canonical tag to make the entry disappear?
You could, but Google would then choose a canonical on its own from signals such as redirects, sitemap entries and HTTPS. Google also recommends a self-referencing canonical on the preferred page, so removing tags usually adds guesswork.
Is the canonical tag a command?
Google's canonicalization page calls it a hint, not a rule, and says Google may choose a different canonical. We found no promise of a specific amount of consolidation, so treat the tag as a strong request.
Related
Sources
- Search Console Help: Page indexing report, accessed 2026-11-12.
- Google Search Central: Consolidate duplicate URLs, accessed 2026-11-12.
- Google Search Central: What is canonicalization, accessed 2026-11-12.