AI search

Why ChatGPT recommends your competitor, and a way to test it

If you ask ChatGPT for the best tool in your category and it names a rival, nobody outside the AI vendors can tell you the exact reason. What you can do is check the documented blockers, compare your pages with the questions buyers ask, and log answers over time. This guide gives you that process.

By Adem ÇakalPublished 3 sources7 min read
Short answer

Work through four checks in order: can the AI search crawler reach your site, are your pages indexed in the search engines, does a page of yours answer the exact comparison or use-case question, and do other sites describe you. Then log answers for the same prompts on a schedule. A citation of your page is not the same as a recommendation of your product.

Start with the buyer questions

List 8 to 12 questions a real buyer types before choosing a tool in your category: "best X for Y", "alternatives to Z", "X vs Z", "how do I do job J". These are the prompts you will test and the pages you must have. If you have none of those pages, the problem is content coverage, and no crawler setting will fix it.

The diagnostic checklist

CheckWhat the vendors documentHow to test
1. Crawler accessOpenAI says sites that opt out of OAI-SearchBot will not appear in ChatGPT search answers, though they can still appear as navigational links. It recommends allowing the bot, and says robots.txt changes can take about 24 hoursAI crawler checker; also look at CDN bot rules
2. Indexed in search enginesGoogle says a page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet to be a supporting link in AI features. OpenAI does not name its search providers in the pages we readSearch Console for Google, Bing Webmaster Tools for Bing; see Bing AI performance
3. A page that answers the questionGoogle says no special markup or AI-specific files are needed; normal search fundamentals apply. Google also says AI features may run several related searches, so pages on subtopics can surfaceCompare your pages with the question list; see alternatives and comparison pages
4. Third-party mentionsNo vendor we read documents mentions as a factor. We treat it as a hypothesis worth testing, not a ruleIn your prompt log, note which sources the answer cites besides yours
Four checks in order: access, indexing, answer coverage, outside mentions, then measure Access bots allowed? Indexed Google and Bing Answers page per question Mentions other sites Fix in this order; a later fix cannot compensate for an earlier block.
Order of work. Steps 1 and 2 are documented by vendors; steps 3 and 4 are judgment calls.

A manual prompt log

Copy this table into a spreadsheet. Run each prompt the same way each time, in a fresh chat, with the same settings, and write down what you see.

DatePromptRunsWe were namedWe were citedRivals namedOther sources cited
2026-11-12best [category] for [segment]52 of 51 of 5Rival A (5), Rival B (3)Two review sites, one blog
2026-11-12[Rival A] alternatives50 of 50 of 5Rival B (4), Rival C (2)One comparison page

The two example rows are placeholders showing the format, not measured results. Repeat monthly, and after each content change, so you can compare like with like. To see actual visits from AI tools, use the GA4 AI traffic regex.

A citation is not a recommendation

A cited page means the system used it as a source. A recommendation means the answer names your product as a good choice. They come apart in both directions: your help article can be cited in an answer that recommends a rival, and a rival can be named with no link to your category page. That is why the log has separate named and cited columns. When you are cited but not named, read the cited page the way a buyer would: does it say who the product is for, what it costs and how it differs from the alternatives? A page that only explains a concept supports the answer without selling you.

What not to conclude

  • One answer is not a trend. Responses vary between runs and over time.
  • Being absent in a prompt does not prove a technical block. Check access and indexing first, since those are the documented causes.
  • A rival being named does not mean they did anything special. They may simply have more pages matching the question.

For the full list of steps with evidence levels, see how to get cited by ChatGPT.

Questions people ask

Is there a list of factors that make ChatGPT recommend a brand?

Not from OpenAI. Its crawler documentation covers access, such as allowing OAI-SearchBot, not ranking factors. Treat any list of ranking factors as someone's hypothesis.

If ChatGPT cites my page, does it recommend me?

Not necessarily. A citation shows a page was used as a source. The answer can still name another product. Log both facts separately.

How many times should I run a prompt?

Answers vary between runs, so one run proves little. We suggest at least five runs per prompt on each date, and recording the count with the result. That is our method, not a vendor standard.

Does Google use different rules for AI Overviews?

Google says a page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet to appear as a supporting link, with no extra technical requirements. That is separate from ChatGPT.

Sources

  1. OpenAI: Overview of OpenAI crawlers, accessed 2026-11-12.
  2. Google Search Central: AI features and your website, accessed 2026-11-12.
  3. Google Search Central: How Google Search works, accessed 2026-11-12.