A trustworthy "X vs Y" or "X alternatives" page states who it is written for, says up front that you publish one of the options, fills every comparison cell from a linked source with a check date, admits where a competitor is the better fit, and uses no invented reviews or ratings. Google's spam policies target pages made mainly to manipulate rankings. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews bans fake reviews and undisclosed insider reviews.
Page anatomy
The comparison table, with sources
Each row needs a criterion that a buyer cares about, a value for every product, and a link to where that value came from. This is the template we use:
| Criterion | Product X (us) | Product Y | Source for Y | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | Amount and billing period | Amount and billing period, or "not published" | Y's pricing page URL | Date |
| Free plan or trial | Terms | Terms | Y's pricing or signup page | Date |
| Integration or platform support | List | List | Y's integrations docs | Date |
| Limits (seats, pages, API calls) | Number | Number | Y's plan documentation | Date |
| Where Y is stronger | Say it plainly | The strength | Docs or your own test notes | Date |
Rules we follow for the cells:
- Pricing: quote the plan name, the amount and the billing period, link the competitor's pricing page and print the check date. If a price is hidden behind a sales call, write "not published" instead of guessing.
- Features: state only what you confirmed in their documentation or in a test you describe. "Not mentioned in their docs" is different from "not supported".
- Unknowns: leave them visible. A blank labelled "unverified" is more credible than a confident guess.
Disclose that you are one of the options
State it near the top, in plain words, with your method. It protects readers, and it protects the page from the claim that it is a disguised ad. The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, effective October 21, 2024, prohibits presenting reviews or testimonials from company insiders without clearly and conspicuously disclosing the relationship. A comparison page is not a testimonial, but the same principle applies to anyone writing about their own product as a neutral judge.
What to avoid
| Shortcut | What the primary sources say |
|---|---|
| Invented or purchased reviews and testimonials | The FTC rule prohibits writing, buying or selling fake or false consumer reviews and testimonials, including through brokers |
| Suppressing negative reviews | The FTC rule covers intimidation, false accusations or unfounded legal threats to stop reviews |
| Hundreds of near-identical "X vs Y" pages | Google's scaled content abuse policy covers many pages generated mainly to manipulate rankings, however they are made, including with AI tools |
| Copying vendor descriptions and reviews | Google's thin affiliation policy flags copied merchant descriptions and reviews with no original content, and it treats original reviews and comparisons as the good case |
| Promising a tool or result you do not deliver | Google's misleading functionality policy |
Every pairing that gets its own page needs its own facts: different criteria, different test notes, different "choose Y if" advice. If a page is the same text with two names swapped, merge it or drop it.
Schema notes
Do not add review or rating markup that you wrote yourself. Google's review snippet guidelines say reviewed entities that control their own reviews are ineligible for star results when they use LocalBusiness or another Organization type, and that markup must describe review content visible to users on that page. Reviews must reflect genuine experience of the item. The page does not address Product markup for your own product, so we leave it out. Plain Article markup, a visible table and visible dates carry the page, and a specific meta description helps the click. To check pairs that compete with each other in search, use the cannibalization finder.
Questions people ask
Can I mark up my own product's rating with review schema?
Be careful. Google's review snippet guidelines say pages of an entity that controls its own reviews, using LocalBusiness or another Organization type, are ineligible for star results. Their page does not address Product markup for your own product directly, so we do not add it to comparison pages.
Is it allowed to name competitors?
Naming a product you compare against is ordinary practice. Keep claims factual, dated and linked to the competitor's own page. We are not lawyers, and trademark or advertising rules vary by country, so get advice before making disparaging claims.
How often should the table be refreshed?
Whenever a source changes, and at least each quarter for pricing. Put the check date next to each priced cell and update the page's visible date only when you actually re-verified.
Should an alternatives page list competitors above my product?
Order by fit for the stated reader, not by who pays or who you are. Put yourself where you honestly belong, say you are the publisher, and include the cases where a competitor is the better choice.
Related
Sources
- Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search, accessed 2026-11-12.
- Google Search Central: Review snippet (Review structured data) guidelines, accessed 2026-11-12.
- FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, questions and answers, accessed 2026-11-12.